To be honest, I hadn’t given much thought to whether illustrations were out of date (technology-wise) before Kristin pointed me to the slide show. (So, thanks!). And, with all the trying to keep up with the latest in technology I do, being in the information biz and all, I had to wonder why I wasn’t concerned with how technology was represented in picture books. She makes some good points about why modern technology is not often featured (it dates the book, technology is not a major concern in the lives of our very youngest, etc.), but I do agree that if an illustrator today makes a decision to include, say a phone, that it wouldn’t hurt if it resembled the kinds of phones that the children would see in their homes or parents’ hands today. But it doesn’t hurt to show a phone that has a cord, either. And, to be honest, I was more thrown by the fact that Mama Llama was wearing a faux pearl necklace than that she was taking a phone with a cord.
First, I’ll probably keep an eye open for technology in picture books now, but I think it will fall into the category of “if it’s done well, I’ll notice and try to remember it, but won’t necessarily lament the lack of it.” I’m impressed when illustrators include things that aren’t written in the text – multiracial characters, wheelchairs, children wearing glasses – but am more concerned that the illustrations reflect the text well.
Second, I don’t think that the lack of modern technology in picture books is the determining factor on whether the kids will relate to the book or not. I could be wrong, but I think the more important issue is whether the readers can relate to what the character is going through. In the case of Baby Llama, the fact that he wants attention is what the kids will identify with. I cannot keep enough copies of Scooby Doo books on the shelves (if you want to talk about a different era, those pictures have not been updated. at. all.) and I suspect that the appeal lies with the characters and the mysteries. And the monsters. Even if a picture book featured some example of modern technology, like a child caring for their Webkinz pet – the more important thing for me would be whether the emotion is authentic, or whether the illustrations matched the tone of the text.
Third, if a 4-year old was obsessed with, say, playing a Star Wars video game, I would help him or her find books about Star Wars before a book about a person who likes video games. If a second grader was obsessed with, say, geocaching, I would help him or her find a book about treasure hunting or exploration before looking for a picture book featuring someone holding a GPS in their hands.
Fourth, and this is slightly off-topic, what’s the rush for preschoolers to get into technology anyways? The technology is not what helps our preliterate children develop their vocabulary, letter knowledge, love of reading, storytelling skills, or understanding of how their language is made up. The technology is not what helps children get ready to learn to read. If the characters in a book are reading a newspaper or watching a non-plasma television rather than catching up on their blogging or watching YouTube, it’s okay with me. And it will probably be okay with the kids, too. (The author of the slide show did not suggest that picture books go that far, just that they show a computer in the home once in awhile.)
Fifth, one of my favorite picture books is Punk Farm. The animals on Old MacDonald’s farm have formed a punk rock band and go on tour with their hit single “Old MacDonald Had a Farm” which features different instruments during the “here a..” and “there a…” parts. The concert is a rousing success, ending with the band giving a big thank you / shout out to their fans in Wisconsin. I have no idea whether their electric guitars and keyboards are modern or not, but I’m Friends with Punk Farm on MySpace, and am a Fan on Facebook.
You must be logged in to post a comment.